Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 vs Gen 2

Hi, I’m Chris. About Me

I’ve been watching the pellet grill market grow year on year in popularity for more than a decade. Traeger was the first to market with a wood pellet grill in the 1980s and is still the market leader to this day. While their top-of-the-range Traeger Timberline pellet grills show what’s possible at the ‘cutting edge’ of pellet smokers, what about their most popular grills? Well, for many years, their most popular grill has been the Pro Series, now in its second generation.

Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 vs Gen 2
For many years, the Traeger Pro Series 34 (left) has been Traeger’s most popular pellet grill. But how does it compare to the Gen 2 Pro Series 780 (Right)?

Update: You may also want to check out my Traeger Pro Series vs Ironwood comparison to see if you would get more value from upgrading or not.

PelHeat Pellet Grill/Smoker Database

Research/compare over 290 pellet grills/smokers on sale today

Introduction To The Traeger Pro Series Pellet Grills

I must admit, I find Traeger’s product names a bit confusing.

On first impressions, before you review the specs, most people would think a product with ‘Pro’ in the title is a manufacturers top of the range (professional) offering.

However, with Traeger, that’s not the case. The Pro Series now sits in the middle of Traeger’s range.

And when the older Gen 1 Pro Series models, the 22 and 34, are finally phased out, the Gen 2 Pro Series models will actually be the lowest cost/entry-level Traeger grills.

Yes, you have their lower cost/more basic offerings, such as their portable pellet grill, the Tailgater, but that’s not a full-sized grill/smoker. As the name implies, its more suited to tailgating.

The Ironwood and Timberline grills are their more premium offerings. I believe Traeger has chosen to put the Pro Series as their mid-range offering because it is their most popular grill.

Traeger’s official video on the differences between the Gen 1 and Gen 2 Pro Series pellet grills

The design, construction and components on all Traeger pellet grills have been very similar across the entire product range up until 2017, when the second generation of Traeger Pro Series grills was launched.

The original Pro Series (22 and 34) had strong BBQ community support behind them, and you will still find many people faithful to these older Traeger pellet grills/smokers.

You could even upgrade older Traeger grills and basic models with the more advanced Traeger Pro Series Controller. On some control panels, you could also adjust the P-Setting.

A notable feature of the Pro Series controller on both Gen 1 and 2 models is the ability to connect an external meat probe to the control panel to monitor internal cooking temperatures. This obviously provides a lot more convenience and enables you to produce even better BBQ.

However, as you will see below, the Gen 2 takes this level of convenience/control to a new level with WiFire integration. You can also fit the Traeger pellet sensor to Gen 2 Pro Series pellet grills.

First, let’s look at the features of the original Gen 1 Pro Series, which is still available today, and for a lower price than the newer Gen 2.

Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 (22 & 34) Overview

The reason I particularly like the video below from the BBQGuys on the first-generation Traeger Pro Series is it accurately and concisely demonstrates the core principles of how a pellet grill operates.

As I’ve been working in the wood pellet industry for so long, I often forget to cover the basics.

The video shows how the BBQ wood pellets flow via gravity to the bottom of the hopper. A horizontal auger then feeds the pellets into the firepot, where a hot rod igniter and an induction fan start the fire.

The temperature inside the grill is monitored by an RTD probe, sending that data back to the control panel to turn the auger/fan on and off. Importantly though, the video discusses how on the first generation Pro Series both the auger and induction fan are fixed speed.

This video discusses the features of the original (Gen 1) Pro Series Traeger pellet grills

The Gen 1 Pro Series features an 18lbs capacity pellet hopper. Now it should be noted that Traeger wood pellets and many other brands come in a 20lb bag. Hence, you cannot quite empty a full bag of pellets into the hopper.

At this point, I do also want to note that its not best practice to empty a bag of grill pellets straight from the bag and into the hopper. There may be excessive dust/fines in the bag from the pellets being mishandled.

Therefore, as I discussed in my Traeger accessories post, you want to use a sieve of some kind to separate the pellets and dust before loading them into the hopper.

The temperature range on the Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 is 150 degrees (smoke mode) up to 450 degrees. The controller then turns the auger and induction fan on and off to regulate the temperature and distribute heat and smoke around the food in the grill evenly.

Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 22 & 34
These are the Gen 1 Pro Series 22 (left) and 34 (right)
  • Total Cooking Area = 572 (22) & 884 (34)
  • Pellet Hopper Capacity = 18 lbs
  • Temperature Range = 180 to 450 degrees
  • Direct-Flame Access? = No
  • PID Temperature Control? = No
  • WiFi/App Control? = No
  • Typical Price = $599 (22) & $699 (34)

Traeger Pro Series Gen 2 Overview

The first difference between Gen 1 and Gen 2 is how Traeger defines the grills. With Gen 1 there were 22″ and 34″ versions, with the number of inches defining the internal width of the grill racks.

With the Pro Series Gen 2, Traeger has decided to define them by the size of the cooking area in square inches. What is important to note about the 575 and 780 is their more vertical pill-shaped barrel.

The increase in height makes it easier to use these grills for cooking certain foods such as beer can chicken. Both the Gen 1 and Gen 2 grills have an 18lb hopper.

Therefore, the Gen 2 grills still cannot take a full 20lb bag of pellets. There are, however some notable and important differences/upgrades between Gen 1 and Gen 2, as discussed in the video below:

This video discusses the features of the upgraded (Gen 2) Pro Series Traeger pellet grills

There are other small differences between the Gen 1 and Gen 2, such as the style of the handles. However, the important differences come down to the control panel.

The Gen 1 Pro Series control panel, while it had a digital display, was actually very analogue in how it controlled the auger/induction fan through the adjustment on the temperature dial.

The new D2 control panel on the Pro Series Gen 2 is all digital and uses a PID algorithm. Hence, it has much more precise control over the auger motor and induction fan.

The other significant difference/upgrade on the Gen 2 is the D2 Direct Drive auger and induction fan, these are now DC brushless motors with variable speed.

Traeger Pro Series Gen 2 D2 Direct Drive
The D2 Direct Drive components of the Gen 2 Pro Series are a big upgrade over the previous generation

What this means is not only quicker start-up times but more precise control of the cooking process and the ability to more quickly respond to temperature fluctuations.

Say for instance, a cold breeze kicks up and is blowing over the grill. Well, Gen 2 is going to be able to keep a more stable internal temperature at the set range. There is no P-Setting adjustment required on the Gen 2 models.

Another important feature that the D2 controller benefits from is WiFire. This means the grill can be controlled via an App on your smartphone. You can download recipes/settings and upload them to your pellet grill.

You can also monitor the temperature of the grill and the internal temperature readings of the heat probe. Take the example of cooking something like brisket that takes many hours and requires adjusting the temperature of the grill over time.

The ability to control the grill with WiFire remotely is simply far more convenient than cooking on a Gen 1 Pro Series model without WiFire.

Traeger Pro Series Gen 2 575 & 780
These are the Gen 2 Pro Series 575 (left) and 780 (right)

Total Cooking Area = 572 (575) & 780 (780)
Pellet Hopper Capacity = 18 lbs
Temperature Range = 180 to 500 degrees
Direct-Flame Access? = No
PID Temperature Control? = Yes
WiFi/App Control? = Yes
Typical Price = $899 (575) & $999 (780)

Benefits Of The Gen 1 Pro Series Traeger Pellet Grills

Its not clear for how long Traeger is going to keep selling Gen 1 Pro Series pellet grills, but I hope its for a while yet because I do think they still have a position in the market.

For instance, if someone has never owned a pellet grill before, the Gen 1 series components and controller have a proven track record of providing good consistent performance.

Furthermore, as I discuss in my post on how to fix a Traeger grill, they are many retailers providing all the parts you need to, in most cases, to easily and cheaply repair these grills.

Traeger Gen 1 Pro Series Benefits
It is easier/cheaper to gets parts for the Gen 1 Pro Series models and the grills which cost on average $300 less than the Gen 2 Traeger Pro Series models

It should also be noted that the Gen 1 Pro Series controller actually has two ports for external meat probe monitoring, whereas the Gen 2 D2 controller only has one external meat probe insert.

Its probably seen as a small difference/benefit to most people, but it should be noted. Another significant difference between Gen 1 and Gen 2 is the price. On average, you will have to spend an additional $300 on a Gen 2 Pro Series pellet grill over a Gen 1 relevant to the different sizes.

Benefits Of The Gen 2 Pro Series Traeger Pellet Grills

There is no discernable difference in the pellet hopper size when upgrading from the Gen 1 to Gen 2 Pro Series. However, it should be noted all Gen 2 grills come with an emptying door on the bottom of the hopper to quickly change over pellet flavours.

What your additional $300 (on average) is getting you is the improved D2 control panel and the improved direct drive/variable speed motors on the auger and induction fan.

In the most basic terms, the Gen 2 Pro Series grills are able to respond quickly and adjust the internal temperature of the grill better than the first-generation Pro Series Traeger pellet grills.

Traeger Gen 2 Pro Series Benefits
The updated Gen 2 Pro Series Traeger pellet grills do cost more. However, the introduction of WiFire could be a ‘game-changer’ in how you can use your time while cooking on the grill

However, its the introduction of WiFire is where the Gen 2 series really shines. With a Gen 1 Pro Series to monitor the cooking process required you have to get up and go and check that digital readout frequently. Along with the fact that Gen 1 is not able to main temperatures as consistently.

To put it bluntly, the Gen 1 Pro Series takes more work to produce that top-end BBQ food, hence the reason for buying a pellet grill in the first place. Then again, it will cost you more money.

So you have to weigh up firstly how often do you intend to use the grill? Secondly, what type of food do you want to cook? Are you into long/slow cooks like brisket? Or are you looking for a grill to just quickly cook steaks and burgers?

Traeger Pro Series Owner Reviews

After spending some time watching several different owner reviews on the Gen 1 and Gen 2 Traeger Pro Series pellet grills, the video I chose to include in this post is from the YouTube Channel Triple 6 Grill.

In this video, Josh does a side-by-side comparison of the old and new generation Pro Series. He shows how much quicker the Gen 2 575 can recover to the preset temperature after the lid has been opened compared to Gen 1.

Josh from Triple 6 Grill does a side-by-side comparison of the Gen 1 Pro Series 34 and the updated Gen 2 575 Traeger pellet grill

Josh also emphasises the additional height between the racks on the 575, which as I have discussed above, is due to the pill-shaped barrel design as opposed to the round barrel design of the older Pro Series.

As Josh states in this review, the original Pro Series 22 and 34 are still great pellet grills, and for your first pellet grill, they are still an excellent choice. However, the integrated WiFire features on the Gen 2 575 & 780 bring the ability to remotely control your grill, which is a very nice feature to have.

Conclusions On The Traeger Pro Series Gen 1 vs Gen 2

My personal thoughts are that if you can afford that additional $300 or so between the Gen 1 vs Gen 2 Pro Series I think the improvements to the design/shape of the grill and components are worth it.

As Josh shows in the video above. If you live in a colder northern climate or you want to cook with your pellet grill during the colder months of the year, there is a clear difference in performance between the Gen 1 and Gen 2 Pro Series.

However, if you cannot afford a Gen 2 Pro Series, a Gen 1 22 or 34 is still an excellent pellet grill to start you on your pellet smoking journey.

Traeger does have some strong competition though, for instance, check out my Traeger vs Camp Chef article. I also have lots of other related posts, please check out my Wood Pellet Grill/Smoker Guide. 🙂

PelHeat Pellet Grill/Smoker Database

Research/compare over 290 pellet grills/smokers on sale today

Recent Posts